“Who Took Misty Copsey?” is an eight-part narrative podcast that delves into the haunting disappearance of 14-year-old Misty Copsey. Over the course of the series, host Sarah Cailean pieces together the mystery through interviews with those closest to Misty, anonymous tips, and deep dives into police records—all in pursuit of answers about what happened the night Misty vanished. This podcast shines a spotlight on a 30-year-old cold case with the hope of uncovering new information, encouraging witnesses to come forward, and ultimately bringing resolution to Misty’s disappearance.
Throughout the season, Sarah Cailean takes listeners deep inside her investigation into Misty Copsey’s disappearance. With exclusive interviews from local investigators experienced in cold cases, heartfelt conversations with Misty’s family and those close to the case, and insights from leading experts, Sarah pieces together the fragments of a decades-old mystery. Sarah Cailean brings unparalleled expertise to the investigation. Currently serving as a Special Investigator for the Mobile County (AL) Sheriff’s Office major crimes squad, she leads inquiries into multiple cold case homicides. She is also a team investigator for the Cold Case Foundation and was recently inducted as an investigative member of the internationally renowned Vidocq Society. With a career dedicated to solving violent crimes, Sarah’s relentless pursuit of justice drives every moment of this series.
The podcast achieved remarkable success across multiple platforms, soaring to #1 on Apple Podcasts in its second week. It didn’t just dominate the charts, it was also featured prominently on Amazon Music’s Times Square Billboard. In addition to topping Apple Podcasts, the show ranked high on Apple and Spotify’s True Crime charts and earned prime placement across major podcast platforms, cementing its status as a must-listen for true crime fans everywhere.
